No criticism from me, looks good. Think it would be nice on a table for napkins and salt and pepper shaker. Or on a desk. Think it looks good enough to buy. The real test though, is post it on Facebook for all your non scrolling friends to see. See how many of them say they want one. That was my mistake with some of my first projects I made. Then I had to make and give them to some good friends and family members. Well thanks for sharing.