Jeff,
I, or no one else can tell you what speed to use. There are so many variables as to blade, wood used, thickness of wood, etc. But, if you are burning the wood, I would say that your blade is too dull or you are pushing and forcing things. (which usually comes from a dull blade) It just comes from experience and your cutting methods.
I know that blades cost money but, when you think about what it costs to buy a dozen blades from Mike, they are not expensive enough to cause frustration....TOSS THE DARN DULL BLADE!!
This is not a race, take your time and just guide the line into the new sharp blade and let it do the work. If the saw seems too fast for your cutting control, slow it down a few notches if the saw seems to be to slow to keep up with your ability to feed the line into the blade, speed it up a notch or two and soon you will think "THAT IS IT!". Just remember, it's working just fine for this job but, it may not be right for the next one. That is why God made variable speed saws.
When I started, my first saw had two speeds, fast and stop.
By the way, Billy has a GREAT IDEA on not only stack cutting two or more puzzles but, putting the puzzle pattern on the back side. That would have helped me immensely had I thought of it a couple of years ago.
Rog